Judi Hodgen-Benson had posted her Biggest Loser Audition video on my Facebook fan page. I figured the best thing I could do is watch it and give my honest opinion. I am posting my feedback here hoping it may help others looking to make an audition video.
I have no expert experience in audition videos but after going through the process for season 5, 6 & 7 I can give you my opinions on what I think they are looking for.
I personally thought your video was terrible. Don’t get me wrong, the stories are very sad and I really do feel sorry for the loss your family has experienced. I felt like your video was terrible because it was way over edited. When you are making an audition video you do not want to put any music to it. Keep in mind, you are auditioning for a TV show. They want to hear you. They want to get an idea of who you are and how you come across on camera. They do not want to listen to songs. There are actually times in your video when your music cuts over the words in your video. When contestants are selected for the show they actually use some of your audition footage in the actual show and therefore your music could ruin a great clip.
The casting directors for the show are watching literally thousands of videos and I would think that you have just a few seconds to make a great first impression. I would have to assume that they are not sitting and watching all 10 minutes of your video. I would not open your video with any pictures or still shots. Eliminate the music. Have someone film for you. If you are auditioning for a couples edition they are going to want to see how the two of you interact with each other. In your video I very seldom see you and your mom together.
The story your mother tells about being an emotional eater due to the loss of her daughter (and other family members) is heart wrenching. She needs to go into more details. She needs to really tell us her story. What is being an emotion eater like for her. If you think about it, you are trying to give viewers at home an idea of what it is like. Some viewers may not have any idea what “emotional eating” is or what it even means.
To me it seemed like Grandma is reading off of a script. The Biggest Loser is a reality show. Grandma is a great addition but have her speak from the heart. Have Grandma tell it like it really is. It will have a greater impact.
Judi when you are talking you talk a lot about other people we want to hear more about you. (Similar to what I say about your mothers story) I want you to make me feel what it is like living in your life. You mention the great connections you have made. I want to hear how your weight has effected those connections. I want to hear exactly WHAT your weight is holding you back from. DETAILS DETAILS DETAILS. I want you to dig deeper than you ever have before.
The friends in your pants is great! I loved the visual. Again…I want more details from your friends. We know they want you on the Biggest Loser. I would like to hear what they really think about how your weight has effected you (from their perspective).
The day at the lake is pretty much pointless. I think that perhaps you are trying to show a fun side of your personality but I think the music ruins it. I would like to hear what is going on. What type of interaction is taking place between you, your friend and your mother. When your mother fell I would have loved to hear you laughing hysterically at her (if that is what happened).
Food shots are always great on the Biggest Loser but I think it would help to go into detail about your eating habits. Explain that it would not be uncommon to come here and eat 4 hot dogs (or what ever you usually eat).
To pretty much sum it up, take out the music. Do not open with still shots. Show you and your mother together more often. Go into greater detail about everything. Really show and tell us what your life is like. Go into your feelings. Your thoughts. Your frustrations. What ever it is you may be feeling. I think it might be helpful to have a good friend come up with a list of tough questions they ask you in an interview style format. You should not see the questions in advance to eliminate prepared answers. The friend should not be seen on camera asking them but sitting behind or on the side of the camera. Repeat the question in your answer and answer from your own perspective. Example: “What is it like when you get into your Jeep to drive” Your response “When I get into my Jeep to drive I ignore the fact that the steering wheel is rubbing against my stomach.”
Most importantly I will NEVER understand why and how I auditioned for season 5 & 6 and still never changed. I looking into a camera and poured my heart out. I told them why I needed it. I told them why I would be good at it. I told them that I was ready to change and yet when they called me back months later I was still the same person I was when I made the videos. I will always encourage people to try out for the show but please keep in mind that you are not really looking to be on the Biggest Loser. You are looking to live a healthier more active life. You are viewing the Biggest Loser the way to get you there but remember it is not the only way. There are many roads that can take you there if you want it bad enough! GOOD LUCK and I hope this has helped!